The math on whether to buy or rent is not a single number. It depends on income, savings, likely tenure, expected capital appreciation, and the borrower's psychology. But the components have shifted enough since 2019 to require revisiting.
What has changed
Borrowing costs have roughly doubled. Rents have grown 30 per cent nationally. Property prices have grown 22 per cent nationally but with wide regional variation. Household savings behaviour is, on average, more disciplined than pre-pandemic. Superannuation balances are larger.
What the honest calculation says
For a household expecting to stay in a property for five years or less, in most Australian cities, renting is likely to be financially preferable. For a household expecting to stay for ten or more years, buying is likely to be preferable, though the margin is thinner than it was pre-pandemic.
The intermediate case, five to ten years, is now the most sensitive to individual circumstances. There is no rule of thumb that survives contact with the specific numbers.