The choice between operating as a sole trader and operating through a company was, for much of the last two decades, a straightforward call in most cases. The changes to small business tax rates from 2020 onward, and the interaction with personal marginal rates, have made the choice less obvious than it used to be.
When sole trader is preferable
For a business with taxable income below roughly $80,000 a year, and with a business owner who does not intend to reinvest significant profit into the business, sole trader status is often simpler and, on net, tax-efficient.
When a company is preferable
For a business with taxable income above $150,000 a year, a company structure is usually preferable, particularly if the owner is willing to leave retained earnings in the business rather than drawing them.
The intermediate case
Between $80,000 and $150,000, the answer depends on drawings, superannuation strategy, expected growth, and personal circumstances. This is the range where professional advice matters most and where the wrong choice can be materially expensive.